Buttermilk Fantails

aka pull-apart rolls

Tomorrow is Thanksgiving, folks! I am so excited. I’ve got my brine cooled and ready to go for the turkey tonight, I’ve got my cranberry chutney made, I’m done with my gravy (because you don’t want to make gravy out of a brined turkey or else you’ll have a bowl of saltiness nobody wants to eat), and I’m making my chestnut stuffing (along with a vegetarian variety made with mushrooms) tonight after work. I am ready to go. All I need to make on the actual day is the turkey, roasted brussels sprouts and squash, a big pitcher of my yearly Thanksgiving cocktail (this year it’s bourbon, apple cider, ginger beer, lemon, and bitters), and a dessert. I’m leaning towards apple cider doughnuts, but we’ll see. After that, I only need to make sure everything is warm. Not so bad, right? It helps that my friends and family are pitching in big time to help make our Thanksgiving a success. I’ve got a grand total of 14 guests this year, and I’m so excited to try what they’re making: vegetarian lasagna (which honestly I think is perfect Thanksgiving food), macaroni muffins, scallion, cheese, and bacon mashed potatoes, ceviche (non-traditional but I love it), miniature apple and pumpkin pies (from my lovely sister-in-law), and monkey bread. I also always put out a big plate of charcuterie, cheese, and crackers, so I think this year’s meal is going to be a big success. Just keep me in your thoughts! This 18-pound turkey is the biggest one I’ve made yet, and I’m just slightly nervous about it. Kramer seems confident, though, so as long as one of us is, we should be good to go. What is on your Thanksgiving menu this year? Inspire me, people!

Buttermilk Fantails

One last thing that’s on my menu are these Buttermilk Fantails. I accidentally bought 2 containers of buttermilk last week, and after trying to find something on theme to make with the buttermilk (and I already made buttermilk pies), I landed on these. I had never heard of a fantail, but they are essentially pull-apart dinner rolls, and man, they are good. There’s not much that is as satisfying as pulling apart layer after layer of buttery, homemade bread, is there? These hit you on a couple of different levels: the buttermilk and touch of honey add a sweet element, while the sprinkle of sea salt evens out the richness. These fantails are great for setting out as an appetizer, or as a part of your meal to soak up gravy and other deliciousness on your holiday plate. Best of all, you can make these ahead of time, freeze them, and warm them up in the oven the day of your meal, although since we’ve only got one day left, if you make them tonight, just leave them out at room temperature, covered, and pop them back in the oven for a few minutes before you’re ready to serve. Keep these rolls in mind for your December holiday plans, too! They really work for all occasions, and travel well, too – I sent my test run batch into my husband’s office and they were eaten up immediately. I hope that you have a wonderful Thanksgiving!

Buttermilk Fantails
First, bring your dough together. You don’t even need a stand mixer for these!

Buttermilk Fantails
Then knead your dough until it is elastic and smooth, form it into a ball, and cover until doubled in size.

Buttermilk Fantails
Next, roll out your dough, brush it with butter, and cut it into long strips.

Buttermilk Fantails
Just look at those stacked buttery layers.

Buttermilk Fantails
Cut them into equal sized squares.

Buttermilk Fantails
Place the squares into your buttered tins, spread the layers apart just a bit, cover, and allow to rise again until doubled in size.

Buttermilk Fantails
Bake until golden brown and set, then brush with a bit more butter and top with a sprinkle of sea salt. Serve warm or room temperature with plenty of gravy and other goodness.

Buttermilk Fantails

5.0 from 1 reviews
Buttermilk Fantails
Prep time: 
Cook time: 
Total time: 
Serves: 12- 14 muffin-sized rolls
Rich pull-apart rolls made with honey and buttermilk.
  • 1 stick plus 2 tablespoons unsalted butter, melted and divided
  • 2 teaspoons active dry yeast (from a ¼-oz package)
  • ¼ cup warm water (105–115 degrees F)
  • 1 tablespoon honey
  • 3 cups all-purpose flour, plus more for kneading and dusting
  • 1½ teaspoons kosher salt
  • ¾ cup well-shaken buttermilk
  1. First, butter muffin cups with 1 tablespoon of melted butter. Stir together the yeast, warm water, and honey in a large bowl and let stand until foamy, about 5 minutes. (If mixture doesn't foam, start over with new yeast). I've made these twice. The first time, the yeast took forever to foam and I thought I'd have to start over, but I let it sit for a full 10 minutes and it foamed up. The second time it happened much quicker. Just be patient!
  2. In a large bowl, mix together your flour, salt, buttermilk, and 6 tablespoons of melted butter into the yeast mixture with a wooden spoon or rubber spatula until a soft dough forms. Turn the dough out onto a well-floured surface and knead, dusting the surface and your hands with just enough flour to keep dough from sticking, until dough is elastic and smooth, 6 to 8 minutes. I found the best way to knead this dough was to slap it down on the surface, pull it towards me, fold it back into itself, flip it over, and do the same for a solid 6 minutes. Form the dough into a smooth ball, then place it in a clean, well oiled bowl. Turn the ball over to coat well, then cover the bowl tightly with plastic wrap and a cloth towel. Place in a warm spot, like the corner of your kitchen, and allow to rise until doubled in size about 1.5 to 2 hours.
  3. When you're ready, punch the dough down (do not knead it), then halve it. Roll out half of the dough on a lightly floured surface with a floured rolling pin into a 12-inch square (about ⅛ inch thick; keep the remaining half covered with plastic wrap). Brush the dough with ½ tablespoon of butter (you may be tempted to use more - do not do this or the rolls will not stick together) and cut into 6 or 7 equal strips.
  4. Stack the strips, buttered sides up, and cut crosswise into 6 or 7 equal pieces. Turn each piece on a side and put into a muffin cup. Make more rolls with remaining dough in same manner. Separate the outer layers of each roll to fan outward, then cover with a kitchen towel and let rise in a draft-free place until doubled and the dough fills cups, about 1 to 1.5 hours.
  5. When you are ready to bake, preheat your oven to 375 degrees F. Bake the rolls until golden brown, 20 to 25 minutes. Brush the tops with remaining 2 tablespoons of butter, sprinkle with some sea salt, if you like, then transfer to a rack and cool at least 20 minutes. Serve warm or room temperature. These will keep well in an airtight container for up to 2 days, or you can freeze them after they've cooled, store in an airtight container or bag, and warm back up in a 350 degree F oven for 10 minutes or so when you're ready to serve.

19 Responses

  1. Molly says:

    Those are beautiful! One of my secret favorite things are the canned biscuits with the “flaky layers”. I used to be very adept at inserting butter and jelly throughout those buggers. These look like another way to add extra surface area for butter, or as I call it, the meaning of life.

  2. Those look incredible. LOVE the layers! I totally want to grab one off the screen and dig right in. Very tempted to add them to my menu for tomorrow … all I need is buttermilk. Hmm… Have a wonderful Thanksgiving!

  3. Good luck with the feast tomorrow! The fantails look tre cool. Happy Thanksgiving!

  4. They are stunning, Sydney! I love the delicate stacks, the golden edges, the fluffy-ness to them. You outdid yourself!

  5. Deb says:

    I used to make a similar recipe, but had forgotten about the buttery chunks of warm sweet rolls! Buttermilk is an enchanting addition to the classic recipe. A wondrous recipe!

  6. Lindsey says:

    oh yummm… girl pull-aparts might be one of my fav carbs on thanksgiving. these look divine.

  7. jen says:

    No fair putting such a pretty, yummy recipe up the day before Thanksgiving–I would have loved to make these!

  8. jules says:

    yummm…i could eat the whole batch.

  9. Elizabeth says:

    These are SO adorable! It’s a good thing that buttermilk is so delicious in so many different recipes!

  10. Lynna says:

    These look so cute! I saw these before and definitely wanted to make them, but totally forgot about them. I`m glad you posted this!

    & Good Luck with Thanksgiving dinner!

  11. Oh my those look great! It sounds like you have quite the Thanksgiving menu going there. Good luck with the turkey;I’m sure it will turn out perfectly. Happy Thanksgiving :)

  12. Happy Thanksgiving!!!! And thanks for the fat and happy rolls :-)

  13. Corrie says:

    These look dooo delicious! Making these someday for sure!

  14. Oh my – I’m loving your Thanksgiving menu – can you come over and cook thanksgiving next year? :)

    I always have buttermilk on hand so you know I’ll be making these fantails. It looks so cute and fun to eat – I’m sure my niece and nephew will have a blast with this!

  15. […] I called a Thanksgiving audible. One of my favorite food bloggers, Crepes of Wrath, posted her buttermilk fantails recipe and I had to make them. Good thing too, they were a total hit! I think they beat out our brined and […]

  16. […] for cold winter nights and for leftovers as lunch the next day! Serve this soup with crusty bread, buttermilk fantails, or, honestly, it’ll sing all on its […]

  17. Kasia says:

    Those look amazing! Now you gave me an idea what to bake next!

  18. Anusha says:

    What cute fantails. Reminds me of mermaids somehow. Pretty Pretty. And bookmarked

  19. hormuz says:

    YUM!! i just made these in Mumbai. Loved them! Family ate them up in a jiffy! Plan to make a new batch – maybe with the tips dipped in chocolate.

Leave a Reply

©2021 The Crepes of Wrath