Honey Shortbread Cookies

flakey & delicate

Kramer and I had grand plans to be lazy on Monday, our exciting day off. However, after a lovely breakfast of bagels and lox (that I am proud to say, I had the foresight to buy the day before) followed by an episode or two of House of Cards, we decided that we’d regret not stepping outside on such a beautiful winter day. There’s something about crisp, cool air paired with plenty of sunshine that just makes me want to get outside. We had started to watch a movie, but then called up our friend Matt to see if he wanted to grab an early drink at Harefield Road in Williamsburg. We all headed over there, and it was obviously meant to be, because did my eyes deceive me? No! They had a big, wonderful bottle of Pappy Van Winkle sitting at the bar. Now, it was only the 15 year, but still. It’s the nectar of the gods, I tell you. It tastes like melted butter, maple syrup, and caramel, all in one. It was unbelievably delicious, and I can only imagine how good the 20 or 23 year variety would be. I’ve heard about how good this stuff supposedly is, and I didn’t quite believe it, so I had to splurge and try it. I am now a changed woman. I just need to track down a bottle of the stuff so I don’t have to pay the crazy price tag that most establishments slap on it (although, rightfully so – did I mention how good it is?). Have any of you ever tried it? Where do you get your Pappy fix? Forget nice champagne or scotch. It’s all about Pappy Van Winkle, as far as I’m concerned. And don’t judge me! If I were talking about a bottle of wine, this would all seem perfectly normal, but just because it’s bourbon doesn’t mean it’s hipster nonsense, as I’m sure Liz Lemon would certainly pass this entire paragraph off as.

Honey Shortbread Cookies

You know your cookies will be good if you leave a messy counter behind.
After my discovery, we walked over to Graham Avenue Meats for their giant godfather sandwiches, which are a revelation all on their own. Hearty Italian bread, crisp on the outside and soft in the center, with loads of quality balsamic vinegar, is the vessel for well over a pound of delicious Italian meats. Sometimes you get different types, but the result is always the same: magnificent. Sometimes it’s prosciutto, salami, coppa, bresaola…whatever they use, I promise, it’s the good stuff. Packed together with roasted red peppers, pepperoncini, and lots of freshly ground black pepper and arugula, this is the sandwich that just screams old school Brooklyn. I really need to take my dad here; why haven’t I done that yet? Anyway, we hauled our food back to Harefield for another beer or two before calling it a day. Kramer and I went home, watched Celeste and Jesse Forever (excellent; please do yourself a favor and see it), then Shameless, then got to bed early, well rested and prepared for the short week of work ahead.

Honey Shortbread Cookies

I feel like if you were going to pair a cookie with a glass of Pappy Van Winkle, it’d be these honey shortbread cookies. They are delicate and flakey, but still rich and buttery, so a nice, smooth bourbon would be an excellent pairing. Our friend Amanda was kind enough to smuggle back a bottle of honey from her family’s vacation home in Nevis, where I’m told they make fantastic honey. If this bottle is any indication, excellent is an understatement. This honey is just lightly sweet, with a caramely, nutty flavor that makes any baked good extra special. This is the browned butter of honey. I feel very lucky to have gotten my hands on it! If you are ingredient-obsessed like me, you know that good honey is not only expensive, but hard to come by. Anyway, if you can’t get yourself some of this sweet, sweet Nevis honey, then any variety will really do the trick, as the layers of butter that melt into one another as the cookies bake make them almost addictive. I can’t explain it, but Kramer and I kept going back for more. This is an odd thing for us to do because, well, I bake a lot and it’s just one of those things that you don’t usually feel the need to go crazy over because there’s always more where that came from. Not in this case; we each had two or three on the first day I made them, followed by one or two more the next day. I had to push them onto Matt and Amanda (hopefully they thought I did the honey justice), then made Kramer take the rest into his office to rid me of the burden of devouring the rest of them. If you’re not a heavy dessert person, then these little guys are for you. Just a touch of honey, the richness of butter, and the crispy, flakiness of those two combined. No chocolate or caramel; just simple tea cookies kicked up a notch.

Honey Shortbread Cookies
The famous Godfather sub from Graham Avenue Meats, Matt enjoying said sandwich, Kramer enjoying Matt’s cat, and my very enjoyable glass of Pappy Van Winkle (oh, was it good).
Honey Shortbread Cookies
So, your ingredients. Take some lovely honey from Nevis (or out of the bear) and add it to your cookie dough. Let it chill for 45 minutes to an hour wrapped in plastic, then roll it out between two sheets of parchment.

Honey Shortbread Cookies
Cut out your cookies into your desired shape.

Honey Shortbread Cookies
Then brush with some warm honey and sprinkle with a touch of sugar. Bake for 11-12 minutes, until golden and set.

Honey Shortbread CookiesHoney Shortbread Cookies
Allow to cool and enjoy…with a glass of Pappy, if you can get it!

Honey Shortbread Cookies


4.7 from 3 reviews
Honey Shortbread Cookies
Prep time: 
Cook time: 
Total time: 
Serves: 30 small cookies
Buttery, delicate honey shortbread cookies with a light honey glaze.
  • 3¾ cup all-purpose flour, plus more for rolling
  • ½ teaspoon kosher salt
  • ¼ teaspoon baking powder
  • 1½ cups (3 sticks) unsalted butter, cubed and room temperature
  • ¾ cup brown sugar
  • ¼ cup honey, plus more for brushing
  • granulated or raw sugar, for sprinkling
  1. Whisk together 3¾ cup of all-purpose flour, kosher salt, and baking powder. Set aside.
  2. Beat together your butter and sugar, until light and fluffy, about 3 minutes, then add in your honey and beat until just combined, scraping down the sides of the bowl as needed. Add in your flour mixture and beat until just moistened (it will be a bit crumbly). Bring the dough together into a ball, packing it together until it sticks, and wrap in plastic. Allow the dough to chill for 45 minutes in the fridge.
  3. When you are ready to bake, preheat your oven to 350 degrees F. Take half of your dough (and keeping the other half refrigerated until ready to use), place it on a lightly floured sheet of parchment or wax paper, sprinkle the top of the dough with just a bit of flour, and place another sheet on top. Roll the dough out to ½-inch thick between two sheets, cut out, then place on parchment lined baking sheets. Heat a few tablespoons of honey in the microwave for just 10 seconds or so, and brush the cookies with the warm honey, followed by a quick sprinkle of sugar. Bake for 11-13 minutes, until golden and set. Allow to cool, remove from the sheets, and serve. These will keep well at room temperature in an airtight container for up to 5 days.


24 Responses

  1. Those cookies look delightful. I’ve got a somewhat ridiculous love of shortbread. It comes together so quickly, it’s almost like insta-cookie (besides the chilling period – which I occasionally “forget”).

    Hope your quest for Pappy comes to a happy conclusion soon! Or you may just have to make the trip out to Frankfort, KY. I hear they give tours…

  2. Stacey Evans says:

    I love honey and I love Shortbread, what a perfect combination. I can’t wait to try these. Our friend that lives in Palm Springs drinks this Pappy and he can’t find it anymore, He wanted us to buy it in Phoenix but we can’t find it either. I hear it is $400.00 a bottle. I love Bourbon and hopefully I will get to indulge someday!

  3. Megan says:

    That sounds like a fun day! I want to drink that nectar of the gods! Sounds so good. I LOVE honey shortbread. And these cookies are so good-lookin’. I’d like to eat 10 in a row.

  4. Rachael says:

    Sent this my brother, who loves baking shortbread cookies to have with tea!

  5. I recently made some shortbread-ish cookies that I havent blogged about yet but omg with that honey (from Nevis!) I bet your cookies are so good!

  6. Cookies + alcohol = a winning combination. P.S. I love “Shameless”!

  7. Elizabeth says:

    Brushing the cookies with honey sounds so delightful!

  8. Anna says:

    The cookies look amazing! Love the close-up photos, and the ridges!

  9. I’m also dying to try Pappy. I can’t stand wine ( I know – I’m weird) but I love trying different hard liquors. I have heard many great things about Nevis and imagine their honey is fab, as well as these cookies. My Mom and I always watch Shameless together. She likes to play it off as she doesn’t really enjoy it, but I always joke it’s the only show she’s never fallen asleep during.

  10. These look so freaking fabulous!

  11. Woah. These look amazing! Sometimes I think that, when it comes to cookies, simple can be best. These gems are proof that I am 100% correct.

  12. lemonkerdz says:

    These look Fab, i love shortbread and the different flavours you can add is endless. one of my favorite flavours at the moment is Orange & Pistachio.
    Thanks love the recipe

  13. I am sort of obsessed with shortbread cookies. These sound amazing.

  14. My husband will totally love these, two of his favourite things, honey and shortbread combined. Thanks again for a great recipe.

  15. Yum! These look incredible Sydney. I’m not suprised that they are delicious.

  16. Lynna says:

    These look so yummy! I feel like I can already taste them from the pictures!

  17. Perfect looking shortbread. Could eat these all day.

  18. Anja says:

    These look beyond yummy! I am a big fan of shortbread, I’ll definitely have to make some myself.

    Pinning this for my next baking binge! 😉

    Anja @ cocalores.blogspot.com

  19. […] incredibly thick, nutty, and perfectly sweet, which makes it excellent for baking. I made honey shortbread cookies with half of it, and I finally finished up my precious bottle by making these muffins. You […]

  20. […] Shortbread Cookies -click for recipe -All I did was cut out a hexagon shape from cardboard and I traced the shape to cut the cookies. I […]

  21. […] Maple Shortbread Cookies from Hunger Angler Gardener Cook 15. Honey Shortbread Cookies from The Crepes of Wrath 16. Lemon Thyme Shortbread Cookies from HeathersDish 17. Pecan Shortbread Cookies {Gluten-Free} […]

  22. Tiffany says:

    So I just have to say, this is now one of my all time favorite cookie recipes. I’ve made them probably half a dozen times… they are so addictive! I use sucanat instead of brown sugar, and sometimes I make them into thumbprints filled with fruit jam. Amazing.

Leave a Reply

©2021 The Crepes of Wrath