Muddy Buddy Pie

with a Chex crust

I made this pie for a potluck at work a few weeks ago. Maybe I’m a little pie crazy this year. Whatever. Don’t judge me. I really wanted to do a pie specific potluck this year in the office, and I’m so glad it happened. Last year we did a general dessert potluck, but I had this image of our boardroom table covered with all kinds of pie and that’s exactly what happened. I was worried that we’d have a hard time getting people to bring in pies, but we had blueberry, apple, peanut butter, berry crumble, peach and raspberry, lemon meringue and so many more. It was heaven. Someone even brought in a crack pie from Momofuku and a salted honey pie from Four and Twenty Blackbirds. Another genius brought in a few containers of ice cream. Be still, my beating heart. I ate more than my fair share of pie that day – probably three or four slices – then sat down at my desk in a sugar coma, counting down the minutes until I could go home and take a nap. I felt bad that Kramer didn’t get to partake in the festivities, so I left him a slice of this Muddy Buddy pie at home as a consolation prize.

muddy buddy pieWorking hard.

So, yeah, this pie was pretty awesome. Muddy buddies are one of my favorite holiday treats, so I figured that a pie with all of the same stuff would be equally delicious. I used Chex Mix for the crust instead of just regular Chex, because I thought the saltiness of the mix would offset the sweetness of the milk chocolate and peanut butter. And it did – wonderfully. The filling was simple – a mixture of creamy peanut butter, milk chocolate, cream and a little vanilla. All you have to do it bake the crust for 10 or 15 minutes, then pour the chocolate filling into the pie, let it chill in the fridge for a few hours, or overnight, dust the top with powdered sugar, and have at it. There couldn’t be an easier pie to make to get you in the holiday spirit. Everyone loves peanut butter and chocolate, and if the rate at which this pie disappeared at our pie potluck is any indication, your friends and family will, too.

muddy buddy piemuddy buddy pieMy Martha Stewart holiday lights, dinner at Ootoya with Jeena, Saturday morning brunch prep and Mitzie Skittles being a lady.

muddy buddy pieYour ingredients. I used Chex Mix instead of plain Chex for this, because I thought the added salt would be nice with the sweet chocolate.

muddy buddy pieCrush your cereal or Chex Mix into fine crumbs.

muddy buddy pieMix with your brown sugar, cinnamon and butter.

muddy buddy pieThen press the crust into the pie dish.

muddy buddy piemuddy buddy pieBake until golden, then set aside.

muddy buddy pieHeat your cream and vanilla until simmering, then pour it over your chopped chocolate and peanut butter and stir until smooth.

muddy buddy piePour the chocolate into your crust, then refrigerate until set.

muddy buddy pieI’m weird and thought cutting a pattern out of paper, then dusting it with powdered sugar would look cool. It ended up looking just okay. If you’re good at cutting stuff out, though, I highly recommend trying this out!

muddy buddy pieRefrigerate for at least 6 hours, or preferably overnight, until set.

muddy buddy piemuddy buddy piemuddy buddy pie

Muddy Buddy Pie
Prep time: 
Cook time: 
Total time: 
Serves: 12-15
Pie made with a Chex crust, rich chocolate filling and topped with powdered sugar.
For the Chex Crust:
  • 2 cups ground Chex cereal
  • ¼ cup packed brown sugar
  • ¼ teaspoon ground cinnamon
  • ½ cup (1 stick) + 2 tablespoons unsalted butter, melted
For the Filling:
  • 1 cup heavy cream
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 2 cups milk chocolate, roughly chopped
  • ½ cup smooth peanut butter
  • powdered sugar, for dusting
  1. Preheat your oven to 350 degrees F. First, make the crust. Use a food processor or blender to crush the Chex into fine crumbs, then toss together with the brown sugar and cinnamon. Add in the melted butter and mix with a fork until well combined. Press the mixture into a 9-inch pie dish, then bake for 10-12 minutes, until golden but not too brown. Set aside, as it will firm up as it cools.
  2. Now make the filling. In a small pot, combine the heavy cream and vanilla. Heat over medium and bring to a simmer for 5 minutes, until very hot. In a heat-proof bowl, add the chopped chocolate and peanut butter. Pour the hot cream and vanilla mixture over the chocolate and peanut butter and stir until melted and smooth. Pour the chocolate mixture into your prepared pie crust, the smooth over the top. Place the pie in the refrigerator and chill overnight, or for at least 6 hours.
  3. When you're ready to serve, dust with powdered sugar. This will keep well, refrigerated, for up to 3 days.


26 Responses

  1. you just turned one of my all time favorite treats into a freaking pie. a pie!!!! i love you.

  2. joyosity says:

    You are a genius! I was just thinking yesterday that I wanted to make some Puppy Chow (that’s what we called the version made with Crispix), but this is even better!

  3. Bhiravi says:

    Oh wow, this looks so good. I don’t even like muddy buddies, but this pie? Yes please. I love the idea of using chex mix instead of chex for saltiness, too. All of my favorite desserts are just a little salty.

    And, great earrings. My little sister had a gold pair similar to those for a while, and they were her favorite!

  4. This is just such a freaking great idea that I can’t even understand how it hasn’t happened before. A whole new world of pie.

  5. Alexandra says:

    I’ve not heard of muddy buddies before, but the concept sounds genius. I can’t believe how easy this pie is to make. Love the combo of crunchy salty crust with a rich filling. Yum!

  6. joyosity says:

    So I tried making this last night and found that I needed way more than 2 cups of cereal to soak up all the butter (and I only used 1 stick) and spread across the bottom and sides of a 9″ tart pan. I ended up using about 5 cups, total! Did you mean 2 cups of crushed cereal?

  7. […] Remember muddy buddies (a.k.a. puppy chow)? Now you can have them in pie form. (Crepes of Wrath.) […]

  8. […] Muddy Buddy Pie with a Chex Crust from Crepes of Wrath […]

  9. […] Muddy Buddy Pie with a Chex Crust from Crepes of Wrath […]

  10. […] Remember muddy buddies (a.k.a. puppy chow)? Now you can have them in pie form. (Crepes of Wrath.) […]

  11. Brooke Bass says:

    Chex mix for crust?? Mind blown. Thanks for sharing such a fun, beautiful recipe! (And, for the record, I would never judge ANYONE for being pie crazy. It’s the holidays, which means you can eat as much pie as you want ;))

  12. Hina says:

    How many ounces of chocolate did you use?

  13. […] The Thursday Thirteen’s – What If Gifts […]

  14. Crispin says:

    I think this may also be good without the PB; maybe add some rum and top with whipped cream instead of the powdered sugar…

  15. […] Muddy Buddy Pie from The Crepes of Wrath […]

  16. Amanda says:

    Did you end up not using the cornstarch pictured?

  17. Debra says:

    This was a big hit at my holiday party last night! Also–good call on the Chex Mix rather than regular cereal.

  18. […] ADAPTED FROM: Muddy Buddy Pie from The Crepes of […]

  19. WAT. damn that looks good.

  20. […] I love desserts that aren’t too sweet, but that are decadent and satisfying. Ladies and Gents, I give you my adaptation of The Muddy Buddy Pie. […]

  21. […] • Joy the Baker Chocolate Mousse Pie with Peanut Butter Whip and Pretzel Crust • Oh, Ladycakes Muddy Buddy Pie • The Crepes of Wrath Strawberry Balsamic Pie • EZy Cooking & More Salted Caramel Pecan Pie […]

Leave a Reply

©2022 The Crepes of Wrath